The Uncommon Appeal of Clouds

The Uncommon Appeal of Clouds

Book - 2012
Average Rating:
Rate this:
Isabel is asked to help a friend discover who stole one of his prized paintings while also dealing with the possibility that her young son Charlie is a mathematical prodigy.
Publisher: Toronto : Alfred A. Knopf Canada, 2012
ISBN: 9780307361882
Characteristics: 259 p. --


From the critics

Community Activity


Add a Comment
Mar 11, 2019

9th title in the Isabel Dahlhousie series.
Oh, the Lovely clouds. Seems Scotland might be famous for the mighty drama of its sudden changing of its skies above, Scotland's spaces.
This plot is less dramatic than other plots in the series. But that's OK.
McCall Smith truly works to present people's characters, character (or lack of it);
the people in the story deal with varying forms of conflict, silent, spoken, or otherwise.
This would be because life is real in its actions and consequences of conflict. Does an understanding of moral philosopy, / ethics, .. Isabel's, ...make a difference to resolutions?
Enjoyable reading. Challenging, poetic, thoughtful writing.

Jun 21, 2014

a light mystery with a philospher sleuth in the soft style of McCall Smith. Always pleasing to read him!

Apr 07, 2013

Surprisingly slow, discursive, and finally, quite self-indulgent. What was essentially an interesting story seems to have been written as a means for Mcall to unburden himself of all his apercus about the human condition, to an extent that tried this reader's patience. While he does this in several of his other series, and certainly his observations and comments are kindly and perceptive, if much too avuncular, I felt this needed much more editing and self criticism. Very disappointing.

If you are interested in the minutia of life in Edinburg from why cars won't start in the damp to whether 3 y/o Charlie should learn to divide and multiply before he starts school, then this is the book for you. The plot eventually rears its sleepy head only to peter out at the end. I promise I will never pick up another book by this author. I'd rather watch paint dry.

Dec 12, 2012

I'm not certain which book the reviewer read, but no foxes were shot in this one!

Nov 30, 2012

One of A. M. Smith's better written Dalhousie books UNTIL the end, where the story seems to just peter out.

HELEN M. ZSUTTY Oct 05, 2012

#9 Isabel Dalhousie series
Another very enjoyable episode in the Isabel Dalhousie series set in Edinburgh, Scotland. The mystery surrounds the disappearance of a very valuable painting. There are the usual side stories involving her husband, Jamie; their 3 year old son, Charlie; her rather "sometimes difficult" housekeeper, Grace; her neice, Cat who runs a delicatessen; and my favorite, Eddie who helps Cat run the delicatessen but has social and emotional issues. I love the last line of this book! Plus this time the outcome of the mystery seems to be left to the reader. My memory is fairly poor and I've read so many of his novels that I'm not sure if this has happened in the other books in the series but it didn't bother me as that is how real life is: sometimes there isn't an obvious answer.

Some readers complain that the pace of his writing is too slow but I love the way his words seem to "flow" across the page. IMO, his characters are so human and have flaws like all of us. One of the reasons that I love Isabel is that she truly does try to see the good in most people.

Age Suitability

Add Age Suitability

There are no age suitabilities for this title yet.


Add a Summary

There are no summaries for this title yet.


Add Notices

There are no notices for this title yet.


Add a Quote

There are no quotes for this title yet.

Explore Further

Browse by Call Number

Subject Headings


Find it at PPL

To Top